It is a whole different thing just because of the kind of fish out there, also depends on the boat and the kind of trip some are a mix of bottom fish which the go to Mexico first and then chase tuna, and some they just going to chase the big tuna , if you going in a mix trip yes you need you arsenal because you just never know what is going to work, the ones when you going only for the big tuna are more strait forward you can get by whit just 3 rods in a mix trip i seen guys whit 15 rods and mini bass proshop for tackle box LOL some guys just bring to much i think 7-8 rods is good for a mix trip , price is not bad if you consider the accommodations and the food plus the opportunity to load on fish, if you ever fish whit them one negative side effect is that you would find all the open charter boats in the GOM so obsolete and in bad shape that is like gonging for a ride in a Freeman and then get in to Panga at least that was how i feel when i started to fish in the GOM well except for the American Patriot that boat is on pair whit the ones in Cali , something else that a found in the way people fish in GOM is that they prove that simple things work instead of having to be worried a bout loading tons of sardines most trips i being every body is key on casting lures and it works ! heck also everybody is on the same lure , i remember my first trip on the NB i was amazed to see that everyone where keyed on trowing the same lure , all i bring whit me was my usual surface irons and a few other lures , i got hit on the surface iron twice but lost them lucky for me the lady in the galley sold me 2 halcos and bam got my frist YF in the GOM so always go whit what the locals are fishing they fish that way for a reason.