Testing Lures in Pool

Discussion in 'Tackle and Rigging' started by nmprisons, Jun 3, 2020.

  1. nmprisons

    nmprisons New Member

    4
    0
    I'm changing hooks out on my poppers and stickbaits. There isn't clear saltwater anywhere nearby for me to test these new hooksets. Can I use a freshwater pool, or is the buoyancy difference significant enough to impact how the lures sit and swim?
     
  2. Kim

    Kim Senior Member Supporting Member

    1,970
    837
    they will tend to sink more than in salt water but that won't affect the lure action.
     
    nmprisons likes this.

  3. jiggawhat

    jiggawhat Senior Member

    3,154
    418
    Probably easier to ask what hooks go on what poppers and lures You have
     
  4. HungryJack

    HungryJack Member

    4,639
    1,457
    Like the other person mentioned,
    they will swim similar in fresh.

    As for how they sit,
    5 gallon bucket,
    3 gallons of water
    14 ounces of salt
    mix well.
    Now you can see how they sit.
     
    jiggingnut and nmprisons like this.
  5. Ryan Johnson

    Ryan Johnson New Member

    3
    1
     
  6. Ryan Johnson

    Ryan Johnson New Member

    3
    1
    You could always change your pool to asaltwater....
     
    jac0023 likes this.
  7. DenisB

    DenisB Senior Member

    5,659
    763
    Only time that testing in salt or freshwater is critical .............is for suspending lures....... or near suspending lures. The effect of the specific Gravity ( SG) difference between fresh & saltwater on lure action for strongly floating or strongly sinking lures is quite small.

    The object of testing new hooksets is comparison to your original setup. Whatever medium you are testing in you just sit them side by side & compare original to new in average flotation height & attitude ( angle at rest).
    Hooks contribute to the total ballast of the lure & affect the righting moments of the lure relatively strongly from their attachment position outside the body.............this is their influence on lure action. If the ballast weight of the hook changes is the same then the buoyancy , attitude & action will be typically the same. Any difference in water resistance in the hook changes has very small effect on lure action as the differences are very small.
    Eyeballing lure buoyancy is OK but a more accurate comparison is simply weighing hook options on a small electronic scale.

    A small group of lures are very susceptible to hook changes ...........these are symmetrical ( lathe turned) lures with no or negligible internal ballast & only tail weights to control casting & attitude at rest.............belly hooks provide essentially the only central ballast weight & provide the only( or vast majority of) righting moments to the lure in its action............ with those lures very small differences in hook changes can have significant effects on action.... eg. Gamma style stickbaits.
     
    explorer and nmprisons like this.
  8. manu

    manu Active Member

    27
    8
    This is a very interesting subject. I don't live near saltwater either and usually test my poppers and sinking poppers in a nearby lake. On only few occasions I have replaced hooks but I will save the detail information provided by DenisB, very interesting. Thank you.