360 Tuna Fishers Forum banner
1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
A fisherman from Australia, Max Garth, wrote a great research posting called Me and GSP. It is long but has a wealth of information about Spectra and Dyneema braided line that I haven't seen anywhere else (link at the end if you're interested). One of his conclusions is that any knot in Spectra can be brought to 100% with the addition of one drop of Loctite 406.

Loctite 406 is a very thin cyanoacrylate (superglue) that wicks into the knot. Although it doesn't bond to Spectra, it penetrates all the microscopic spaces in the braided line and it has a very high shear strength. Some believe that the drop of glue keeps the knot from slipping. It certainly reduces Stress Concentration at the first turn in the knot which may be the larger effect.

I have meant to test this idea myself for a while. Here are the results I got today:

Daiwa PE4 55# 8-strand Boat Braid
Actual Breaking Strength (ABS): 54#
Overhand Knot Breaking Strength: 33# (60%)
8-turn Uni Knot Breaking Strength: 38# (70%)
8-turn Uni Knot plus one drop of Loctite 406 Breaking Strength: 54#
100-turn Bimini Twist Breaking Strength: 54#

The Uni Knot is tied to a 150# coastlock swivel. I only made these measurements once or twice which is not a large sample. My margin of error is 2.5 pounds which could mean that any % could be reduced by 5%.

Me and GSP
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,025 Posts
Thanks for posting the information. I will give it a try.
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
4,723 Posts
Can you get this stuff at a local home depot or something? I don't seem to see it listed on homedepot.com though.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
Can you get this stuff at a local home depot or something? I don't seem to see it listed on homedepot.com though.

I had to search for it on the web. Finally I bought a small tube on Amazon from Techni-Tool, $4.75. Loctite makes a range of cyanoacrylate glues, the key is that this one is the lowest viscosity so it penetrates the spaces in the knot.

The guy who came up with this idea, Max Garth, has fished it for years, including multi-day soak testing in his pool. One thing he stresses, more is not better. One drop, at the mid-point of the knot is the right amount, according to him. That's what I tested.
 
G

·
pamet - have you tested what regular superglue does? i'm just wondering how big of a difference this makes. ive always used regular superglue with good results, but if this is significantly better that's good to know.

thanks for testing all this stuff by the way :)
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
pamet - have you tested what regular superglue does? i'm just wondering how big of a difference this makes. ive always used regular superglue with good results, but if this is significantly better that's good to know.

thanks for testing all this stuff by the way :)

Bret, The key with Loctite 406 ($4.75 for a little tube) is that it is low viscosity (watery not syrupy) and so it wicks through the fibers. Max Garth, the first to bring this idea to my attention, has said that thicker superglues don't work because they don't wick in, they just sit on top.

I bought my tube on Amazon from Techni-Tool.

Interestingly, even Loctite 406 doesn't bond well to Spectra (unless you buy the surface activator which is why Jerry Brown glue is two steps). However, because it fills all the voids, it forms a plug through the knot.

To me, this means that you could connect two Spectra lines, uni to uni, and get a very strong connection.

Max is very specific about only using one drop in the middle of each knot and he has used this for years. You don't want the blob of glue to get too big and too brittle.

I appreciate your comments, I've got several more things in the works.
 
G

·
thanks, great info.

the super glue ive used is not viscous as far as super glues go (I think), but im going to buy the 406 just to see how much less viscous that is. interesting that the glue doesnt bond to spectra. definitely did not know that.

have you tried the stuff on a P.R. knot? i always dab some on my half hitches at the end....i'm wondering how big of a difference it makes.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Pamet,

Great info. Have you tried braid to mono or fluoro, uni to uni with the loctite?

I have not tried that but Max has.

First, the Loctite 406 does bond to mono and fluoro (even though it doesn't bond to braid without surface activation ala Jerry Brown adhesive).

Max uses this in a system where he puts Spectra inside braided-hollow-core-mono and then he splices that, then puts one drop of glue on the splice. He has used it for years and extensively tested it.

Let's say were were using uni-to-uni for a braid to fluoro leader connection. Here are my thoughts:

After making and pulling tight both unis in your normal way:

--put a drop of glue on the braid uni, this will take the the stress concentration (and any tendency to slip) out of the braid knot. It will also attach the braid uni to the mono/fluoro line.

--leave the mono/fluoro uni alone. the loctite won't penetrate to the core of that knot so it won't take the stress concentration out of its first turn.

If you can tell me more about the knot you had in mind, I might have some further thoughts.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
thanks, great info.

the super glue ive used is not viscous as far as super glues go (I think), but im going to buy the 406 just to see how much less viscous that is. interesting that the glue doesnt bond to spectra. definitely did not know that.

have you tried the stuff on a P.R. knot? i always dab some on my half hitches at the end....i'm wondering how big of a difference it makes.

If you put your superglue on a knot and it quickly wicks in, then it might work. This 406 is pretty thin but even it sat on top for a moment and then rapidly wicked in and seemed gone, none on top.

Funny enough while I was responding to fish4stripers I was thinking about the Mid and P.R. knots.

My first reaction is that I would not use it on those knots. Here are my reasons.

--The strength of those knots (and they're about 100%) comes from two things: 1. As you pull on the main line, it grabs the fluoro even tighter. 2. Because the angle between the main braid line is low, there isn't stress concentration build-up as in "normal" knots. If you put glue on it, it might interfere with the normal continuous tightening of that knot.

--The purpose of the half-hitches is to be a fulcrum for the main line to work against as the knot pulls up. If I could get the glue on them in such a way that the main line would still slide through them, that would be okay. But the 406 wicks so fast that I think it would get everywhere.

For these knots, since the half hitches on the fluoro are the fulcrum and the half-hitches on the main line hold the other half-hitches from coming loose on the fluoro, here I think a thick super glue that sits on top of the tag end of the braid would be good to keep the second set of half-hitches in place. (I use it on Biminis that way.)
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
474 Posts
Great info. I will definitly give this a try. Thank you.

One question, how fast does the Loctite 406 dry?
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
4,723 Posts
Great info. I will definitly give this a try. Thank you.

One question, how fast does the Loctite 406 dry?

That was gonna be my question as well, how fast does it dry? According to specs, it drys in 15 secs, but is that the case in reality? Certain brands of superglue take forever to dry up, so you can't fish the line immediately in water.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
198 Posts
pametfisher said:
After making and pulling tight both unis in your normal way:

--put a drop of glue on the braid uni, this will take the the stress concentration (and any tendency to slip) out of the braid knot. It will also attach the braid uni to the mono/fluoro line.

--leave the mono/fluoro uni alone. the loctite won't penetrate to the core of that knot so it won't take the stress concentration out of its first turn.

QUOTE]

Thanks, This sounds like a good way to try.

I fish for BFT on the bank and CCB. Over the off season, I'm going to try the Mid not and the PR knot. These knots are new to me. I think one of these will be my off boat knot. For on the boat, I'm trying to find a good knot I can tie easily on a bobbing boat. I've toyed around with slim beauty and triple surgeons but my confidence in tying them well is not up there on them.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
That was gonna be my question as well, how fast does it dry? According to specs, it drys in 15 secs, but is that the case in reality? Certain brands of superglue take forever to dry up, so you can't fish the line immediately in water.

I agree with you, superglues seem to take a while to dry. I would put it on, wipe of these excess, if any, after it wicks in, and then wait a few minutes.

Even if not dry, I don't know if water would rinse it out of the knot.

For the test, I put it on and then did something else for 15-20 minutes and then came back to it.
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 ·
fish4stripers said:
pametfisher said:
After making and pulling tight both unis in your normal way:

--put a drop of glue on the braid uni, this will take the the stress concentration (and any tendency to slip) out of the braid knot. It will also attach the braid uni to the mono/fluoro line.

--leave the mono/fluoro uni alone. the loctite won't penetrate to the core of that knot so it won't take the stress concentration out of its first turn.

QUOTE]

Thanks, This sounds like a good way to try.

I fish for BFT on the bank and CCB. Over the off season, I'm going to try the Mid not and the Page Ranking knot. These knots are new to me. I think one of these will be my off boat knot. For on the boat, I'm trying to find a good knot I can tie easily on a bobbing boat. I've toyed around with slim beauty and triple surgeons but my confidence in tying them well is not up there on them.
Here is a link to one that I have used extensively in CCB and the bank. It pulls up very reliably since it has a stop knot, is the same size as the Slim Beauty. It has the pros and cons compared to the Mid. See what you think.

SIG Knot Steps
 

·
Senior Member
Joined
·
1,386 Posts
Discussion Starter · #17 ·
Not wanting to go on opinion or just an analysis, I looked at this question further. Although Loctite 406 adheres to mono line, it doesn't seem to improve knot strength but it doesn't harm it either.

I tested it with 30# mono, here are the numbers:

34# Actual Breaking Strength
18# Overhand Knot Break (50%)
26# 5-turn Uni Knot Break (75%)
28# 5-turn Uni plus Loctite 406

Although this is a slight improvement, I add weight at 2.5 lbs. per step so the improvement is equal to my margin of error.

The loctite sits on top of the knot and does not wick in. That could prevent slipping but won't improve stress concentration at the first turn in the knot. The results seem to bear that out.
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top